Love it? Share it!

Inside: Newborn not sleeping? You may be making these crucial baby sleep mistakes! There’s no manual for your new baby, but there are a few simple habits you can start right now to learn how to make your newborn sleep better. Learn how to get your newborn to sleep without being held, and help your baby be a confident sleeper!

Newborn not sleeping? You may be making these crucial baby sleep mistakes! There's no manual for your new baby, but there are a few simple habits you can start right now to learn how to make your newborn sleep better. Learn how to get your newborn to sleep without being held, and help your baby be a confident sleeper!

I couldn’t hold it in any longer. “I just can’t. I can’t do this!” My husband was leaving for work for the first time after our first child was born.

I was about to be alone with the baby. The baby who wouldn’t sleep. The baby who was crying in his swing while I silently sobbed beside him.

I needed help!

Three and a half years later, and I’ve learned a lot. I graduated from the sleep school of hard knocks. We finally conquered baby sleep, and went on to tackle toddler bedtime tantrums, too!

Know what? There are a ton of things we did (and are still doing) right with my oldest when he was a baby.

We limited screen time, read books like they were going out of style, cultivated his character, and created a lot of great memories together.

Yet, I’ll be the first to tell you that I seriously sabotaged his sleep! It wasn’t intentional at first, we just didn’t know any better.

I’m not beating myself up over it…We just didn’t know what was really possible with a few simple baby sleep principles.

But this time around…

Fast forward to baby #2…With a baby girl here, we’re doing things differently this time. Will temperament and personality play a part? Certainly.

Yet I’m positive that there are a few key factors I’m changing that are helping my second baby sleep better than my first from the very start.

Hindsight is 20/20, right?

So, mama. Learn from my mistakes! Are you frustrated with your newborn not sleeping? Take the actions steps to fix those bad sleep habits as soon as possible.

Trust me, you won’t regret it! Let’s get started with my best baby sleep advice on how to make your newborn sleep.

Overwhelmed at home with your baby, toddler, or preschooler? Help is here! Download my Everyday Calm eBook and Printable Pack bundle, and learn simple mindsets and routines to conquer the chaos at home with kids.

Looking for baby sleep tips for a particular age? Check out these posts:

Newborn not sleeping? Don’t make these 6 baby sleep mistakes!

Newborn Sleep Mistake #1: Settling for “Snacks” Instead of “Meals”

Before you can hope for a baby who sleeps well, you need to work on helping your baby eat well. Here’s what I’ve learned about how feeding your newborn well can help build good sleep habits, too.

  • Feed your baby as soon as they wake up from a nap, not just before they go down to sleep.
  • Full bellies mean naps will be the proper length and your baby won’t wake up hungry before her sleep cycle is done.
  • For nursing mamas, let your baby nurse as long as possible on one side to make sure she gets the more filling hind milk.
  • Yes, it’s OK if she only takes one side per nursing session! It’s better to take one side than to try for two and only give the baby fore milk. I like to stroke my baby from ear to chin to encourage her to keep eating.
  • I know it’s tempting to let the baby fall asleep in the middle of a meal. “She’s finally asleep! Now I just won’t move for the next two hours as my whole arm gradually loses feeling.” But don’t do it, mama! Wake that baby up and help her belly get completely full. You’ll be thankful you did when she naps like a champ.

Read my best tips for breastfeeding for new moms!

Action Step: Do everything in your power to make sure your baby really fills up at each meal. No snacking allowed!

Newborn Sleep Mistake #2: Allowing Extended Wake Time

With my first baby, I finally realized that he was chronically overtired. It’s harder for your first, since you’ll likely have more visitors and a less predictable schedule.

Protect the Nap!

For newborns, wake time is usually no more than an hour. I’ve found that 45 minutes is closer to their perfect “nap window.” Protect those naps, mama!

If your baby is staring off into space it doesn’t mean she “just wants to be up.” It means she’s overtired and you need to get her down for a nap quick!

Steal my daily baby and toddler schedule! Plus grab a printable schedule for your fridge to help you keep your sanity.

You can watch for sleepy cues like fussiness and rubbing her eyes, but it’s easier to just watch the clock. about 30-45 minutes after your baby wakes up, start heading for sleepytown.

With diaper changes and feeding, this may mean that you only have 5-15 minutes for cuddles and tummy time. That’s ok!

Wake times will gradually increase over time, but if you try to extend them out too early your baby will always be too tired to fall asleep on her own.

Action Step: Beat chronic over-tiredness by putting your baby down for a nap close to 45 minutes after she wakes up.

Newborn Sleep Mistake #3: Rocking to Sleep Every Time

With baby number one, we rocked him to sleep or put him in the swing for every nap and every bedtime. He was “in arms” about 90% of his day.

It’s a vicious cycle because I extended his wake time too long, which made it impossible for him to fall asleep on his own.

  • With baby number two, I put her down in her bassinet for naps. Our simple nap time routine is a one-minute bounce in my arms while I hum a hymn softly. Then I put her down while her eyes are still slightly open and awake.
  • If we are out and about and off our schedule, I will attempt to rock her to sleep to protect the nap. (Remember mistake #2?) However this is a rarity rather than the go-to strategy.

I think the biggest help in this area is changing your mindset. Instead of thinking, “She will never be able to go to sleep on her own!”

Think, “I can help her learn to fall asleep on her own. It just takes time and repetition.” Go put the pacifier back in as many times as it takes. If she gets really upset, do your simple pick up and put back down routine.

It might take a few minutes at first as your baby learns what to expect. (Which is why you should start naptime before your baby is overly tired!)

But each time you put your baby down sleepy but awake, you’re forming a habit of expectation. Yes, she’s capable! Like my mama always says, “If you can do it once, you can do it twice. If you can do it twice, you can make it a habit.”

If your baby is older than four months, she might be ready for a lovey. Introducing a lovey is a great way to help your baby get to sleep on her own.

Action Step: Decide on a super-short naptime routine. Bounce, hum, put the baby down sleepy but awake. And stick to it!

Newborn Sleep Mistake #4: Rushing in at Every Whimper

If you put your baby down sleepy but awake, you’ll be amazed at how naptimes are naturally extended. The first time I tried this with my second baby, I was absolutely shocked!

About 45 minutes after my daughter went to sleep, she started to whimper and turn her head from side to side.

Now with my first baby, I would have rushed in silently lamenting the fact that he always took short naps. He wasn’t able to settle himself since he needed me to rock him to sleep.

Teach Your Baby to Self-Soothe!

  • With my second baby though, I always give her the chance to settle back down by herself. And it works!
  • As she transitions to her next sleep cycle, she will fidget and grunt for a minute then go back to sleep. As a newborn, her naps are consistently two hours long.

If you’re looking for more in-depth plan on teaching your baby to self-soothe, I highly recommend the book “The Happy Sleeper” by Heather Turgeon and Julie Wright. One of the techniques is called the Sleep Wave, which is the absolute perfect balance between attachment parenting and cry-it-out techniques. This book is a mama-friendly, baby-friendly, science-backed, and real life practical guide for helping your baby sleep well. A friend of mine recommended it to me, and I’m passing on the favor!

Action Step: Invest in a great video monitor. We love our Summer Infant InView 2.0 monitor! It’s worth it’s weight in gold and will prevent you from waking up your baby completely as she transitions in-between sleep cycles. When your baby starts to fidget and fuss, give her a few minutes before going in to soothe her.

Newborn Sleep Mistake #5: Letting Baby Sleep Too Long in Daytime

Once you finally get your baby to sleep, it seems so right to just let her sleep as long as she wants to. Never wake a sleeping baby and all that, right?

In the daytime, though, you set the schedule for when your baby naps and eats. For newborns you’ll generally be on a three-hour schedule. I follow the EASY routine, and it works great!

For my first baby, however, I was so desperate for rest that I let him sleep for four or five hours during the day once I finally rocked him to sleep. Of course this mixed up his days and nights and consistently led to night owl sessions with baby number one.

For my second child, I’m sticking to our schedule. About three hours after she last ate, I wake her up to feed her.

After a few weeks of working really hard to create a predictable schedule, I’ve found that she naturally wakes up within 10-15 minutes of our scheduled time.

Note: if my baby wakes up hungry before three hours, of course I feed her! This point goes back to mistake #1: fill up those bellies as much as you can in the daytime.

Action Step: Create a predictable three-hour routine in the daytime. Eat, awake for no longer than 45 minutes- 1 hour, sleep for two hours. Rinse and repeat!

Newborn Sleep Mistake #6: Neglecting the Bedtime Routine from Day One

In those early weeks with my first baby, I felt like I was lucky to get a shower every day, let alone think about setting a routine for my baby.

Bedtimes happened kind of by accident when the company left or we nodded off to sleep. There was no structure at all!

Try our newborn bedtime routine:

  • This time around, our newborn bedtime routine starts at around 7:30 every night. When she wakes up from her last nap, I’ll give her a warm bath in the bathroom sink. I keep the lights low and hum a hymn to her to keep her calm.
  • I love using mild soap for my babies, not your typical “baby soap.” We’ve had great success with Kirk’s Castile Soap and Dr. Bronner’s Baby Mild Castile Soap. (These helped wonders with my children’s eczema as well!) Then I give her a quick massage with coconut oil to lock in all that moisture and help her relax.
  • After bath time, we nurse in a dark room, swaddle, and put her down sleepy but awake in her bassinet.
  • For bedtime, we use this amazing combo pack n’ play, bassinet, and changing table. It’s tucked in the corner of our master bedroom to make night-time feedings quick and easy.
  • Side note… All swaddles are not created equal! The best swaddle (and the only one you’ll ever need) is the Woombie. Read how we found the perfect swaddle in this post right here!

Make bedtime extra special by praying Psalm 19 over your child. Download the free printable Psalm!

Action Step: Choose two or three elements, such as bath, song, and nursing. Do them in the same order in the same environment every night to create sleepy cues for your newborn bedtime routine.

Your Turn

Baby sleep advice doesn’t have to be complicated, mama. If you avoid these six baby sleep mistakes, I know you’ll be on your way toward a successful newborn bedtime routine.

Start with just one trouble spot at a time, and you’ll soon be on your way towards great baby sleep!

Can I tell you a secret, mama? I’m so glad I’m putting in the hard work up front with my second baby. She is turning out to be a confident sleeper!

Frustrated with your newborn not sleeping? Take action on the steps above. Which of these sleep tips can you put into practice?

Comment below with your newborn sleep experiences!

Love it? Share it!